Pharmaceutical companies' capital, influence, and labor force well equip them to assume responsibility for public medication disposal programs. Government- and industry-funded campaigns for medication disposal do work, but responsibility often falls on local health care organizations to provide education and services. Lack of public awareness about how to dispose of medications and the ramifications of contaminating our natural resources and ecosystems with pharmaceuticals suggest a need for collaboration among pharmaceutical companies, government officials, clinicians, and patients.
Global pharmaceutical spending has risen from $887 billion in 2010 to $1.27 trillion in 2020.1 The World Health Organization defines pharmaceutical waste as expired, unused, and contaminated drugs and vaccines.2 In the United States, unused prescription medications cost the health care industry approximately $5.4 billion per year for adults who take one prescription medication daily.3 Moreover, disposal of regulated medical waste, including pharmaceuticals, costs 119% more per pound than regular trash.4
As part of a recent shift toward a more environmentally conscious culture in global health care, reducing the environmental impact of pharmaceuticals has become imminently important to preserving soil and water quality and maintaining ecological balance.5 National research studies have revealed the presence of pharmaceuticals in streams throughout the United States, including medicines from the following drug classes: antidepressants (eg, fluoxetine), antibiotics (eg, ciprofloxacin), antihypertensives (eg, lisinopril), and analgesics (eg, acetaminophen, ibuprofen), as well as hormone modulators (eg, estradiol-containing drugs).6- 9Quiz Ref IDGlobally, 631 of 713 pharmaceuticals were found in concentrations above the detection limits, 16 of which were found to be in surface, drinking, and ground water in some countries in Africa, the Asia-Pacific region, Eastern Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean, and Western Europe (including North America, Australia, and New Zealand).10 Diclofenac (a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug) was among the top 5 most detected substances in all the regions tested.10 Previously, Diclofenac was linked to critical endangerment of 3 species of vultures after causing widespread kidney failure.11
Designating responsibility for the source and removal of waste is challenging because there are multiple levels of waste generation throughout the life cycle of a pharmaceutical product—starting with manufacturing and extending through clinical use and patient excretion of active drug compounds. Minimizing pharmaceutical waste and increasing proper disposal involve collaborative efforts among stakeholders. Manufacturers are liable for improving packaging and procurement strategies, while governments must provide infrastructure and legislative enforcement. Lastly, clinicians must be more conscious when prescribing and dispensing, and patients must be more conscious when using pharmaceuticals. Throughout the pharmaceutical life cycle, all stakeholders have a responsibility within the scope of their expertise to reduce waste and pollution.
A great deal of work is currently being done to reduce health care's plastic wastage, which constitutes approximately 30% of all health care waste.12,13 Plastics used for medical purposes, such as inhaler actuators and bottles, are predominantly made of polypropylene (PP), which, due to its complicated composition, is seldom recycled (eg, less than 3% of the total PP used).14,15 Updating current recycling standards from incineration and landfilling to methods with less environmental harm, such as fast pyrolysis and gasification, is crucial if plastic use continues.16
Pharmaceutical packaging is a growing industry that was valued at about $89 billion in 2019.17 Pharmaceutical packaging includes plastic stock bottles, unit dose blister packs, medication delivery devices, and intravenous bags, among other items. Promoting the use of plastics that are more readily recycled, such as polyethylene terephthalate or high-density polyethylene, could improve the recyclability of pharmaceutical packaging and reduce costs through the use of recycled plastics.18,19 Novel ways to recover aluminum and polyvinyl chloride from blister packages have also been explored using techniques such as electrohydraulic fragmentation, which can recover 88% of the aluminum used in blister packs.20 Hydrometallurgy is another technique that can achieve 100% separation and recovery of blister pack components.21 Given their ability to be recycled effectively, blister packs have the potential to become a sustainable alternative to dispensing medication in plastic bottles.
The optimization of product size based on clinical use offers another approach to reducing wasteful packaging. In 2016, cancer drugs alone accounted for $1.8 billion in wasted medication due to leftover drugs in single-dose vials.22 Differentiating between outpatient and inpatient package sizes can also reduce wastage. Albuterol, a short-acting beta-2 agonist used to manage asthma exacerbations, is manufactured to deliver up to 200 doses per inhaler.23,24 In most states, once a multidose medication has been opened for use in an inpatient setting, it cannot be given to patients to take home at discharge (unless it has a proper prescription label),25 and, instead, discharged patients are given a list of medications that they must fill at an outpatient pharmacy.26 Therefore, a used inhaler in an acute hospital setting can be discarded with viable doses left over.
Stakeholder responsibility. Quiz Ref IDThe cradle-to-grave approach describing the life cycle of pharmaceutical products—resource extraction, manufacturing, transport, consumption, and disposal—supports the idea that pharmaceutical companies be held responsible for disposal of medications.27 One successful manufacturer-led program, GlaxoSmithKline's Complete the Cycle program in the United Kingdom, recovered more than 2 million inhalers from 2011 to 2020, amounting to the equivalent of the carbon dioxide emissions produced by 8665 cars in one year.28,29 The program ended with a call to other industry leaders to follow suit in creating long-lasting change.29
Health care professionals are also responsible for proper disposal of medications because they play an important role in patient education. Although most clinicians lack knowledge of recommended disposal methods and drug take-back programs,30 the impact of environmental health on patient health is becoming a growing concern.31 By increasing awareness of disposal services, the amount of potential medical waste can be reduced. Pharmacists, in particular, are uniquely positioned to educate the public on medication disposal, given their medication expertise, accessibility, and service as the usual last point of contact for patients.32 However, there are major barriers to promotion of disposal services at the pharmacy, including cost, training, and workflow challenges.33- 36
Quiz Ref IDAlthough patients are major contributors to improper medication disposal due to lack of awareness or access to disposal services, misunderstanding of expiration dates, and medication stockpiling,37 many patients are receptive to disposal services after learning about them.38,39 Updating patients' prescription labels to include information such as disposal locations is worth exploring, as it has been reported that patients are interested in learning more about their medications.40 However, doing so would require support from regulatory bodies, such as the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), to ensure consistent enactment of policy.
The government can play a significant role in promoting proper disposal and should be held responsible for providing infrastructure for disposal, supporting public education campaigns to create awareness of disposal programs and to reduce waste, and enforcing environmental mandates for manufacturing. In Australia, the government-funded Return Unwanted Medicines (RUM) Project has collected unwanted medicine since 1998.41 Utilizing pharmacists as the major workforce, the RUM Project collected over 704 tons of medication in 2016.41 According to a 2016 survey, more than 82% of people previously did not know of the RUM Project, but more than 90% who were previously unaware stated they would use RUM after learning about it.41 Environmental drug manufacturing mandates include the waste-minimizing packaging strategies mentioned earlier in addition to updating drug development strategies to include green chemistry techniques.42 The Sustainable Chemistry Research and Development Act of 2019 marks an important step toward innovative drug discovery research by aiming to minimize environmental harm from emissions and harsh solvents, creating biodegradable active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs), and other measures.43 Although the bill, passed as part of the National Defense Authorization Act, is promising, its feasibility is questionable, as the law currently does not provide any federal research funding for sustainable chemistry research.44
Government approved disposal methods. The Environmental Protection Agency recommends that pharmaceuticals collected via take-back programs be incinerated at licensed facilities, but re-collected medication is currently not regulated under current federal hazardous waste laws.45 Incineration is considered the most effective method for API destruction and is regarded as safe, given that emission controls are in place.46 The FDA supports household disposal methods and offers general instructions to mix drugs with a noxious substance (eg, cat litter, coffee grounds) before disposing of them in a sealed container with normal trash.47 However, household disposal of medications generally exposes drugs to the environment via landfill leachate, which can contaminate water and soil systems.48
The FDA also endorses a list of medications that are safe to be flushed down the toilet, given their high potential for diversion and unsafe ingestion.49 Current research on APIs on the FDA's “flush list” indicates that there is negligible ecological risk associated with their release into the environment; however, it is unlikely that this method can be supported as a long-term solution.50 Innovative at-home technologies have been developed, such as chemical degraders, which render APIs inert, but these options suffer from cost and accessibility limitations.51
Quiz Ref IDQuiz Ref IDPharmaceutical disposal is an emerging concern with both economic and environmental implications.3 Much of our understanding of the environmental impact of pharmaceuticals has come from recent advances in analytical technologies.21 However, the low levels of pharmaceuticals in the environment being detected can also be attributed to overestimating the efficacy of current methods put in place to control waste. Treating waste as “out of sight, out of mind,” allows continued waste production that may not stop until the problem becomes irremediable. Leaching of pharmaceuticals into the environment from manufacturing sites has impacted aquatic ecosystems and the health of communities around the world,52,53 while the accumulation of pharmaceuticals via trash and sewer drains has also led to traceable levels of contamination in municipal waters.54- 56
These findings suggest an important gap in stakeholders' knowledge of pharmaceutical pollution and their responsibility to reduce it. Overall lack of awareness among clinicians and patients remains a major reason why household pharmaceuticals are disposed of inappropriately.57 Encouraging pharmacist education on proper disposal could lead pharmacists to think more critically about pharmaceutical waste production58 while also empowering patients to take part in protecting their ecological communities. Patient education can be delivered by health care professionals at any stage of care, particularly at the stage of dispensing of medication by pharmacists, as the medication experts.59
All stakeholders have a responsibility to reduce pharmaceutical waste. Using innovative solutions to reduce the amount of pharmaceutical packaging predestined for landfill or incineration is a developing area that is the responsibility of pharmaceutical manufacturers.21 Developing a better understanding of waste patterns through information learned from disposal programs can be used to reform product manufacturing, prescribing, and dispensing behaviors to improve safety and health outcomes by reducing the risks associated with polypharmacy and accidental ingestion when there are numerous drugs in the home.60,61 Although medications are commonly disposed of via garbage, drains, or take-back programs,62 returning medications to the pharmacy is medically responsible and should be the most recommended option. Governments should support disposal of pharmaceuticals as a medical service; manufacturers should produce pharmaceuticals with waste minimization and disposal in mind; and health care professionals should feel confident in their knowledge and training to carry out their role as stewards in reducing pharmaceutical waste. Given the accumulating evidence of pharmaceuticals' improper disposal and unintended contamination of ecosystems,63- 65 it is imperative to create collaborative solutions and to promote pharmaceutical stewardship to contain the problem while preventative strategies can still be effective.
Sign in to take quiz and track your certificates
The AMA Journal of Ethics exists to help medical students, physicians and all health care professionals navigate ethical decisions in service to patients and society. The journal publishes cases and expert commentary, medical education articles, policy discussions, peer-reviewed articles for journal-based, video CME, audio CME, visuals, and more. Learn more
AMA Journal of Ethics
AMA J Ethics. 2022;24(10):E971-979.
AMA CME Accreditation Information
Credit Designation Statement: The American Medical Association designates this journal-based CME activity for a maximum of 1.0 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit(s)™. Physicians should claim only the credit commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity.
CME Disclosure Statement: Unless noted, all individuals in control of content reported no relevant financial relationships.
If applicable, all relevant financial relationships have been mitigated.
Conflict of Interest Disclosure: The author(s) had no conflicts of interest to disclose.
The viewpoints expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the AMA.
Ladan Karim-Nejad is a fourth-year pharmacy student at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond and co-founder of the Sustainable Pharmacy Project. Previously, she was a recipient of a research award from the American Association of Colleges of Pharmacy and a RISE DAAD Scholar; Kayla Pangilinan is fourth-year pharmacy student at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond, an active leader in 4 pharmacy organizations, and a co-founder of the Sustainable Pharmacy Project. Previously, she worked as a pharmacy technician and research assistant in medicinal chemistry.
Credit Designation Statement: The American Medical Association designates this Journal-based CME activity activity for a maximum of 1.00 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit(s)™. Physicians should claim only the credit commensurate with the extent of their participation in the activity.
Successful completion of this CME activity, which includes participation in the evaluation component, enables the participant to earn up to:
It is the CME activity provider's responsibility to submit participant completion information to ACCME for the purpose of granting MOC credit.
You currently have no searches saved.
You currently have no courses saved.