How Will This Toolkit Help Me?
Learning Objectives
Examine evidence supporting the case for sharing visit notes with patients
Identify how to educate team members on the new federal mandate for open notes
Discover resources to learn how to write notes that will be shared with patients and help clinicians, patients, and caregivers make the most of them
Shared visit notes, which are also sometimes called open notes, are everyday clinician notes made readily available (“open”) to patients. There is no difference between an open note and a typical clinician note.
The concept of shared clinical visit notes is not new. Individual physicians and organizations started exploring the potential of transparency in clinical records in the 1970s.1 The first efforts to study the impact of shared visit notes on physicians and patients began in 2010—and thus, the OpenNotes movement was born. The movement started as a pilot with 105 primary care physicians across 3 large medical institutions sharing notes with 20 000 of their patients.1- 3 OpenNotes is now an international movement based out of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, a major Harvard Medical School teaching hospital. As a group, OpenNotes studies and disseminates its findings on the effects of shared visit notes on patients, care partners, and clinicians. OpenNotes works with collaborators around the country and overseas to study transparent communication in health care. OpenNotes does not develop software and it is not a technology company. OpenNotes is fully funded by grants and philanthropic gifts. Although as of 2020 more than 50 million patients in the United States and Canada had access to their visit notes, recent US legislation is mandating that visit notes be open to all patients.4
The Information Blocking Rule specifies that clinical notes are among the electronic health information (EHI) that must not be blocked, while allowing for some specific exceptions. The 8 types of clinical notes that must be shared include5:
Consultation notes
Discharge summary notes
History and physical
Imaging narratives
Laboratory report narratives
Pathology report narratives
Procedure notes
Progress notes
In addition to the 8 required types of clinical notes, there are 8 types of exceptions that fall under 2 general categories that involve (1) not fulfilling EHI requests and (2) procedures for fulfilling EHI requests.7,8 OpenNotes often highlights exceptions from the first category, which covers preventing harm, privacy, and safety concerns. These 2 examples are types of clinical notes excepted from the Rule's definition of EHI that would fall under the first category:
Psychotherapy notes, written by any health professional, which are separated from the rest of the individual's medical record; and
Information compiled in reasonable anticipation of, or use in, a civil, criminal, or administrative action or proceeding.
This toolkit will help you and your team address common clinician concerns and provide guidance on best practices for sharing clinical notes with patients. In addition, the AMA has developed a 2-part resource to help physicians understand and comply with the regulations.
Six STEPS for Your Practice to Successfully Share Open Notes
Educate Your Team About the Benefits of Open Notes
Address Practice-Specific Concerns
Prepare Patients and Their Care Partners
Adapt Documentation Style
Learn How to Handle Challenging Topics
Collect Feedback and Refine Your Approach
STEP 1 Educate Your Team About the Benefits of Open Notes
As with anything new, there may be some initial skepticism about open notes. Discuss the importance of transparency with your team and answer questions about open notes during team meetings. Educate team members on the benefits of open notes while addressing legal requirements. Studies have shown that note-sharing provides benefits to both patients and physicians.
Benefits for Patients
Research shows that patients who read their notes say they2,3,11- 18:
Feel more in control of and engaged in their health care
Recall their care plan more accurately
Are better prepared for visits
Have a better understanding of their medical conditions and medications
Are more likely to adhere to their medications
Are able to identify clinically important errors in their notes
Are not more worried or offended after reading their notes
Have more successful conversations and stronger relationships with their doctors
Benefits for Clinicians
Quiz Ref IDResearch shows physicians and other clinicians who shared their notes reported2,3,9,10:
Improvements in patient satisfaction, safety, communication, and education
Improvements in the patient–physician relationship, including enhanced trust, transparency, communication, and shared decision-making
Patients who are better prepared for their clinic visits and are becoming more actively involved in their own care
No increase in time required needed to address patient questions about their notes
Willingness among physicians to recommend to colleagues the use of open notes
As described previously, some organizations adopted open notes years ago. For example, clinicians at the Mayo Clinic have been sharing all visit notes with patients since 2013. There are opportunities to network and learn about best practices from other organizations and physicians who have already implemented open notes. OpenNotes and others have created resources that explain the benefits of shared visit notes and offer tips for using them in your practice.
Pocket Card (609 KB)This card gives a brief overview of how open notes can benefit patients and clinicians.
OpenNotes by the Numbers (61 KB)This fact sheet reviews the evidence for open notes.
Implementation Toolkit from OpenNotes (356 KB)Additional information for practices preparing to use shared visit notes.
STEP 2 Address Practice-Specific Concerns
It is important to take into account the various policy considerations that your practice or organization may have, such as:
Whether any notes created prior to implementation will automatically be shared with patients
How notes that deal with sensitive topics (eg, adolescent health, mental health, obstetrics) will be handled
How patient questions regarding notes will be handled
How important errors found by patients will be corrected
How proxies (ie, care partners) will access patient notes
Who will educate patients on registering for the patient portal and on how to find their notes within the portal
Who will educate physicians about the changes
To further prepare team members, provide department leaders and/or your organization's CEO with a template email they can send to team members. It is also helpful to post information about adopting open notes on your practice or organization's intranet site.
STEP 3 Prepare Your Patients and Their Care Partners
To prepare patients and their care partners:
Send an email introducing open notes and how it will impact them.
Make patient-specific FAQs available in all waiting rooms, in exam rooms, on your patient portal, and wherever else your patients may easily access them.
Post information about adopting open notes on your practice or organization website and patient portal.
Supply easy-to-reference pocket cards that describe the benefits of open notes for patients and clinicians.
Promote the adoption of open notes through your practice's and/or organization's marketing channels, such as the practice newsletter, Facebook page, or Twitter account.
Patient FAQs (886 KB)This handout provides more background on open notes and answers common questions patients have about this new approach.
Waiting Room Poster (860 KB)Add your logo to this poster that explains open notes and hang it in your practice.
Depending on the type of EHR your practice uses, you may be able to create an automatic reminder system so patients know to review their notes before their next visit. Reminders are proven to increase note-reading rates.30
As your practice gains more experience with open notes, help spread the word and continue to engage your stakeholders by:
Collecting stories from patients and clinicians in your practice who are using open notes and share them through your practice's and/or organization's marketing channels, such as the practice newsletter or website.
Asking patients and clinicians to blog about their experiences with open notes and to consider sharing these experiences on social media using #opennotes.
Committing to track open notes utilization by both patients and clinicians so you can regularly update stakeholders with the findings.
Adding questions about open notes to your patient satisfaction survey.
STEP 4 Adapt Documentation Style
Quiz Ref IDYou or your team don't need to make dramatic changes to your writing style because patients will now be able to view notes. In the original OpenNotes pilot, clinicians were not required to change how they were writing their notes. In a recent follow-up survey of clinicians at the 3 original pilot sites, some did acknowledge adjusting their documentation to:
Eliminate language that might be perceived as critical of the patient.
Remove terms such as “non-compliant,” “patient denies,” and “patient refuses.”
Change how they document sensitive clinical, mental health, or social information.
Convey this need to medical assistants, nurses, and anyone else on the team who contributes to team documentation.
General note-writing strategies include:
Being positive and supportive.
Writing only about things discussed with the patient during that visit.
Not including commentary that could be interpreted as labeling or judgmental. For example, instead of “patient is obese,” write “Patient has BMI >30.” Instead of “Patient refuses to take his medications,” state “Patient has been non-adherent to medications due to [provide a reason].”
Minimizing the use of medical jargon, acronyms, and abbreviations. Dot phrases, the autocorrect function on Epic, and other EHR tricks can help streamline this. This change may feel overwhelming for some clinicians, but do not panic—not all medical terms need to be changed, only the ones that may be misinterpreted as offensive. At the end of the day, there are not many of these. Some examples of important ones are “sob” (expand to “shortness of breath”) and “FU” (expand to “follow up”).
STEP 5 Learn How to Handle Challenging Topics
Long before the open notes initiative, clinicians worried about how to document challenging topics such as mental health, obesity, substance use, physical abuse, driving privileges, visits with potentially litigious patients, or suspicions of life-threatening illness. Sensitive issues clearly require special attention.
Although it is natural to want to curb or avoid some challenging conversations, patients may benefit from direct dialogue. For example, when a clinician notices signs of dementia, depression, or impaired driving, the chances are high that the patient and/or family members are already worrying about these issues as well. They may find that a balanced discussion helps alleviate their anxiety.
The best approach in many situations is to discuss with the patient everything you are putting in the patient's visit notes. Use the same words in conversation that will appear in the notes. Many clinicians already follow this practice, and some dictate notes with their patients present. Also, be direct and respectful when addressing concerns with the patient. Document your discussion using supportive language.37 You could also “monitor” notes if this functionality is allowed through your EHR vendor.
Because of the complexity and sensitivities with mental health, OpenNotes has a comprehensive section devoted to this topic.
Examples of Well-Written Mental Health Open Notes (96 KB)Experts share scenarios and sample notes.
STEP 6 Collect Feedback and Refine Your Approach
You can collect information on the use of and perspectives about open notes through informal hallway conversations, at team meetings, and by adding questions about open notes to your patient satisfaction survey. Another option is to track the volume of patient emails and phone calls before and after open notes as an indirect measure of the effect of open notes on clinician time spent fielding patient questions. You can also work with your EHR vendor or IT team to quantify how many patients view their notes via the patient portal.
At the end of the day, most practices are surprised by how much of a non-event transitioning to open notes is. Share stories about open notes (good and bad) in appropriate settings, and incorporate such experiences in case discussions, conferences, and team meetings. Sharing both good and bad experiences will bolster the collective wisdom, empower all roles on the care team, and guide writing better, more transparent notes.
The Future of Open Notes
Practices are encouraged to innovate and tailor how they use open notes to increase patient involvement in collaborative care. As you explore new features and functionality for your patient portal, consider ways that you can make it easier for patients to contribute to their medical records and visit notes. Some ideas for engaging patients include:
Equipping patients to upload home measurements, such as blood pressure and glucose readings.
Enabling patients to update or correct family and social histories in their own words.
Asking patients to contribute to the note by writing the “subjective” portion of the “subjective, objective, assessment, and plan (SOAP)” note before a visit. This may be especially useful in the current era of COVID-19 and telemedicine visits.38
Patient Experience Survey (101 KB)This patient satisfaction survey includes basic questions about how patients are using open notes.
Giving patients access to information in their medical records can improve the patient–physician relationship. Research emerging from the now decade-old open notes movement has demonstrated benefits for both patients and physicians. What was once a voluntary practice taken on by early implementers has now become a federal mandate as a component of the 21st Century Cures Act and the Interoperability and Information Blocking Rule. Sharing open notes engages patients, builds trust, and enhances transparent communication practices. Research and dissemination efforts continue on both a national and an international level.
Journal Articles and Other Publications
Videos and Webinars
Websites
About the Information Blocking Rule Mandate
About shared clinical notes/open notes
Four tips for writing visit notes suitable for your patients to see. Quick Tips: a blog from the FPM journal. January 4, 2020. Accessed March 17, 2021. https://www.aafp.org/journals/fpm/blogs/inpractice/entry/transparent_visit_notes.html
Open notes for health professionals. OpenNotes. Accessed March 16, 2021. https://www.opennotes.org/opennotes-for-health-professionals/
Effects of open notes: FAQs for clinicians. OpenNotes. Accessed March 17, 2021. https://www.opennotes.org/effects-of-opennotes-faqs/
Implementation. OpenNotes. Accessed March 17, 2021. https://www.opennotes.org/implementation/
Communications. OpenNotes. Accessed March 17, 2021. https://www.opennotes.org/communications/
Pediatrics & adolescents. OpenNotes. Accessed March 17, 2020. https://www.opennotes.org/pediatrics-adolescents-clinicians/
Care partners. OpenNotes. Accessed March 17, 2021. https://www.opennotes.org/care-partners-professionals/
Mental health. OpenNotes. Accessed March 17, 2021. https://www.opennotes.org/mental-health-professionals/
Lin CT. How to write an open note for patients: 2020 edition. OpenNotes. Accessed March 17, 2021. https://www.opennotes.org/news/how-to-write-an-open-note-for-patients-2020-edition/